Spirit vs American Airlines: Ultimate Comparison of Fares, Comfort & Service

When you compare Spirit vs American Airlines, the primary distinction lies in their business models. Spirit Airlines operates as an ultra-low-cost carrier, offering significantly lower base fares while charging extra for nearly all additional services, including carry-on bags, seat selection, and beverages. American Airlines, on the other hand, has higher base fares but provides more amenities in its pricing, such as complimentary snacks, in-flight entertainment, and standard baggage allowances. 

The basic economy fare of American Airlines is closely similar to Spirit’s base fare. The main difference, however, is that American Airlines permits a carry-on bag, whereas Spirit does not. This difference greatly influences the experience each airline provides, catering to various types of travelers. Let’s examine Spirit Airlines vs American Airlines more closely to see which one might suit your travel needs better.

Key Factors of Spirit vs American Airlines

Below mentioned are some of the factors that differentiate both the airlines with each other:

1. Pricing and Fees

Spirit Airlines:

Spirit Airlines is widely known for its ultra-low-cost model. This means that its base fares are among the cheapest in the industry. However, the passengers are required to pay an additional cost for nearly every additional service, from carry-on luggage to in-flight snacks. This a la carte pricing system allows budget-conscious travellers to customise their expenses but can lead to unexpected costs for those who are not familiar with the model.

American Airlines:

American Airlines offers a more traditional airline experience by including more in its base fares. Depending on the fare class, passengers might enjoy free checked baggage, complimentary refreshments, and access to in-flight entertainment. Although ticket prices are higher, they typically come with fewer unexpected fees.

Verdict: Spirit is the better choice for travelers who prioritize cost savings, while American Airlines offers better value for those who appreciate bundled services.

2. In-Flight Experience

Spirit Airlines:

The in-flight experience on Spirit Airlines is pretty straightforward. The seats offer limited legroom with a 28-inch pitch and don’t recline, which fits their low-cost model. There are no entertainment systems or Wi-Fi, and passengers must buy food and drinks while on board.

American Airlines:

American Airlines provides a more comfortable journey, featuring wider seats and additional legroom (30-32 inches), along with the possibility to upgrade to premium classes. Many flights include in-flight entertainment systems, Wi-Fi, and complimentary snacks or meals, depending on the route.

Verdict: American Airlines stands out for its comfort, amenities, and long-haul travel options, while Spirit is more suited for short, budget-friendly trips.

3. Network and Destinations

Spirit Airlines:

Spirit Airlines specializes in domestic and leisure travel, connecting more than 90 cities, including well-known vacation destinations such as Las Vegas, Orlando, and Cancun. To maintain lower fares, it frequently operates from secondary airports.

American Airlines:

American Airlines has one of the largest networks in the world, serving more than 350 destinations in 50 countries. Key hubs like Dallas-Fort Worth and Miami offer extensive connections for both international and domestic travelers.

Verdict: American Airlines is more suitable for international travel and business routes, whereas Spirit caters to leisure travelers seeking affordable options.

4. Loyalty Programs

Spirit Airlines:

Spirit’s Free Spirit program is straightforward, but it lacks the extensive rewards found with traditional airlines. You can accumulate points based on your spending and redeem them for flights, but you won’t enjoy elite perks such as complimentary upgrades or lounge access.

American Airlines:

American’s AAdvantage program stands out as one of the most extensive loyalty programs available, allowing members to earn miles through flights, shopping, and using co-branded credit cards. Elite members benefit from advantages such as complimentary upgrades, access to lounges, and priority boarding.

Verdict: American Airlines provides a loyalty program that is more beneficial for frequent flyers.

5. Reliability and Customer Service

Spirit Airlines:

Spirit Airlines often receives negative feedback about its reliability, as numerous customers have experienced delays and cancellations. Many find the customer service to be lacking, and the no-frills model offers little support during travel disruptions.

American Airlines:

American Airlines is recognized for its dependability and offers comprehensive customer support. Although delays and cancellations may occur, they are typically handled with rebooking alternatives and effective communication.

Verdict: American Airlines surpasses Spirit in terms of reliability and customer service.

6. Baggage Policies

Spirit Airlines:

Spirit Airlines charges fees for carry-on bags, checked luggage, and oversized personal items. If you buy baggage fees online ahead of time, you usually get better rates, but keep in mind that prices can rise sharply at the airport.

American Airlines:

American Airlines allows most passengers to bring a free carry-on bag and a personal item. While checked baggage fees can vary, they are frequently waived for elite members or specific fare classes.

Verdict: American Airlines has more favorable baggage policies, especially for frequent travelers or those with elite status.

7. Overall Value

Spirit Airlines:

If you’re on limited funds and don’t mind giving up some comfort and extras, Spirit Airlines is a fantastic choice. The extremely low cost of its type makes it ideal for leisurely holidays or quick domestic travel.

American Airlines:

American offers a well-rounded travel experience that emphasizes comfort, reliability, and inclusivity. It is frequently the top choice for longer flights, international trips, or for travelers who prioritize convenience over saving money.

Conclusion: Which Airline Is Better?

Choosing between Spirit vs American Airlines really comes down to what you value in your travel experience. Spirit is a great option for those looking to save money and who are okay with a basic service model, which works well for short domestic flights. In contrast, American Airlines provides greater comfort, dependability, and additional amenities included in the fare, making it a better choice for longer journeys, international travel, and those who prefer a more conventional airline experience.

Frequently Asked Questions